The story of the first Thanksgiving is often retold in modern America as a sentimental tale of friendship, harvest abundance, and shared meals. While those elements are part of the history, they do not capture the true heart of the celebration. For the Pilgrims who gathered in Plymouth in 1621, the event was not merely a harvest festival—it was an act of worship. The Pilgrims were not just adventurers or settlers. They were Calvinist, Puritan believers who left their homeland precisely because they desired to worship God according to Scripture, free from the domination of state-controlled religion. Their lives, and thus the first Thanksgiving, were deeply shaped by a theology rooted in God’s providence, sovereignty, and covenant faithfulness.
A People Formed by Calvinist Convictions
The Pilgrims (more properly, the Separatists) were heirs of the Reformation. Their pastors, including William Brewster and others influenced by the writings of John Calvin, believed that Scripture alone must govern worship and all of life. They rejected the idea that the king—or any earthly power—could dictate how God’s people should approach Him. Their journey across the Atlantic was not one of political rebellion or economic opportunism, but one of obedience. In their own writings, they repeatedly referred to themselves as God’s pilgrims, strangers in a foreign land, seeking a place to freely worship their Lord.
This identity was rooted in the doctrine of God’s sovereignty. They believed that every trial, every blessing, every disappointment, and every deliverance was under the wise rule of the Lord. When storms battered their ship, when disease claimed their loved ones, and when hunger threatened their survival, they did not interpret these things as randomness or fate—but as part of God’s wise and intentional purposes for His people.
Providence in the New World
The Pilgrims’ arrival in New England was marked by hardship. Nearly half of them died during the first winter. And yet, their writings are not filled with bitterness, but with expressions of trust. They believed God had led them there.
One of the clearest signs of providence came through the help of the Wampanoag people, particularly Squanto. Squanto spoke English—something humanly improbable—and taught the Pilgrims how to grow native crops and survive the climate. Governor William Bradford later wrote that Squanto was a gift of God’s mercy, saying he was “a special instrument sent of God for their good.”
The Pilgrims saw their survival not as the result of ingenuity or luck, but as the gracious care of a sovereign God who provides for His people.
The First Thanksgiving Was a Worship Gathering
When the harvest of 1621 came in, the Pilgrims called for a feast—but this was not just a feast. It was a public thanksgiving to God.
In their Calvinist tradition, a “thanksgiving” was a recognized religious observance, much like a fast day or day of prayer. It involved:
- Corporate worship
- Public prayers
- Psalms sung by the congregation
- Testimonies of God’s faithfulness
- And a shared meal rejoicing in His provision
The first Thanksgiving was, in essence, a worship service with a meal attached—not a meal with worship added.
As Bradford and Edward Winslow recount, the gathering lasted several days and included prayer, fellowship, hospitality, and mutual exchange of goodwill with the Wampanoag. The Pilgrims were not celebrating simply the harvest—they were celebrating God, who had provided the harvest.
Thanksgiving as Theological Witness
The Pilgrims believed what the Apostle Paul teaches:
“Give thanks in all circumstances; for this is the will of God in Christ Jesus for you.”
—1 Thessalonians 5:18
Their thanksgiving was born out of suffering, not comfort. Their gratitude testified to the God who gives and takes away, who disciplines and rescues, who tests and sustains.
Recovering the True Meaning Today
Much of modern culture has emptied Thanksgiving of its deepest significance. It has become a holiday of food, family, and football. But the first Thanksgiving calls us to something richer and more enduring:
- To recognize God as the giver of every good gift
- To thank Him not only for abundance, but even in adversity
- To remember that our lives are sustained by His sovereign hand
The Pilgrims teach us that thanksgiving is not seasonal—it is a posture of the heart rooted in who God is.
Conclusion
The first Thanksgiving was not merely a cultural milestone. It was a moment of worship—an acknowledgment of God’s gracious providence. The Pilgrims, shaped by their Calvinist faith, gathered not simply to celebrate a successful harvest, but to honor the God who had guided, preserved, and supplied their needs.
In remembering this, we are invited to join them—not around a rustic wooden table in the wilderness, but in the same posture of humble and joyful gratitude to the sovereign God who still provides for His people today.
Doctrine and Mission 
Leave a comment